On this day in football

17 May

What happened in football on 17 May, from 1904 to 2023, oldest first. Every line is checked against its source.

  1. 1904
    Carlisle United

    Carlisle United mark 17 May 1904 as their formation date.

  2. 1934
    Peterborough United

    Peterborough United were founded at a public meeting at the Angel Hotel on 17 May 1934.

  3. 1979
    Shrewsbury Town

    On 17 May 1979, Shrewsbury clinched the Third Division championship with a 4-1 home victory over Exeter City.

  4. 1987
    Gillingham

    On 17 May 1987, Gillingham lost 4-3 at Sunderland after extra time but advanced from their play-off semi-final on away goals after a 6-6 aggregate draw.

  5. 1990
    Manchester United

    On 17 May 1990, Lee Martin scored the winner as United beat Crystal Palace 1–0 in the FA Cup final replay.

  6. 1995
    Chesterfield

    Chesterfield beat Mansfield Town 5–2 after extra time at Saltergate on 17 May 1995 to win their play-off semi-final 6–3 on aggregate.

  7. 1998
    Cheltenham Town

    On 17 May 1998, Cheltenham won the FA Trophy at Wembley by beating Southport 1-0.

  8. 2007
    Bristol Rovers

    On 17 May 2007, Rovers reached Wembley by winning 5-3 at Lincoln City in the League Two play-offs.

  9. 2008
    Cardiff City

    On 17 May 2008, Cardiff lost the Wembley FA Cup final 1-0 to Portsmouth, with Kanu scoring the winner.

  10. 2009
    Torquay United

    Torquay regained Football League status by beating Cambridge United 2-0 at Wembley on 17 May 2009.

  11. 2014
    Arsenal

    On 17 May 2014, Arsenal won the FA Cup by beating Hull City 3-2 after extra time at Wembley.

  12. 2015
    Bristol Rovers

    On 17 May 2015, Rovers regained Football League status by beating Grimsby 5-3 on penalties after a 1-1 draw.

  13. 2019
    Charlton Athletic

    On 17 May 2019, Charlton reached the League One play-off final by beating Doncaster Rovers 4–3 on penalties after a 3–2 second-leg defeat left the aggregate score at 4–4.

  14. 2022
    Nottingham Forest

    On 17 May 2022, Forest reached the Championship play-off final on penalties despite losing 2-1 to Sheffield United.

  15. 2023
    Manchester City

    On 17 May 2023, City beat holders Real Madrid 4–0 at the Etihad to reach the Champions League final with a 5–1 aggregate victory.

Sources15The club, the league, The FA or established media
  1. 1904, Carlisle UnitedCarlisle United FCOfficial
  2. 1934, Peterborough UnitedPeterborough UnitedOfficial
  3. 1979, Shrewsbury TownGrecian Archive: University of ExeterEstablished media
  4. 1987, Gillingham11v11 / Association of Football StatisticiansEstablished media
  5. 1990, Manchester UnitedThe Football AssociationOfficial
  6. 1995, Chesterfield11v11: Association of Football StatisticiansEstablished media
  7. 1998, Cheltenham TownThe IndependentEstablished media
  8. 2007, Bristol RoversThe GuardianEstablished media
  9. 2008, Cardiff CityThe GuardianEstablished media
  10. 2009, Torquay UnitedThe GuardianEstablished media
  11. 2014, ArsenalThe Football AssociationOfficial
  12. 2015, Bristol RoversBBC SportEstablished media
  13. 2019, Charlton AthleticSky SportsEstablished media
  14. 2022, Nottingham ForestBBC SportEstablished media
  15. 2023, Manchester CityUEFAOfficial

Spotted a mistake? Tell the Editor and we'll put it right.